When I first began to write seriously, I was surprised to find out that using the omniscient point of view, as our great authors of 200 years ago did, just wasn’t done anymore.
“What is point of view anyway?” I wondered. I thought all I had to do was pretend that as the author, I knew everything and I could see into every character’s head and tell what each one thought and felt.
That may have been all right in times of old, but apparently it is frowned upon in modern times, and aspiring authors certainly don’t want to be frowned upon before they even make their debut.
Point of view, usually called POV, is not, as some might at first think, someone’s opinion. It refers to the character through whom we are seeing the story unfold. As the writer, I can pretend that my main character has a camera mounted on his or her head, and whatever this magic camera can see, hear, touch, smell, feel, or know is allowed to be told. The “camera” cannot know what another character is thinking, unless the thoughts are spoken aloud in dialogue. So I am limited in what I can tell about another character’s emotions. I’ve had to become more skilled at letting the reader know what a secondary character might be feeling, through dialogue and by showing that character’s body language. Are his fists clenched? Is his jaw working? Are his eyes filling with tears? Are his eyes narrowing and his brow furrowing?
POV can be a problem if the POV character is not present in a scene that needs to be told. For that particular scene or even a chapter, the main character may be someone else, and the camera can be in that person’s head for the duration of that section. Just be sure the reader can immediately identify the POV character in the first sentence or two. The writer needs to stick to one person’s POV for each scene and not go “head hopping” throughout the scene.
Some of the most popular POVs used are first and third person (“I” and “he” or “she”), and can be in the past or present.
I would like to give you some short examples of some POV types.
First I want to show you something really, really horrible that I discovered in my novel, Marlie — a blatantly obvious (to everyone but me) POV error. In the section marked in red, I had slipped into first person when I should have been in third person POV. I have fixed that error and now I can sleep at night.
He took hold of both my upper arms and looked into my eyes. “Is it so hard to see that I really care about you?”
She swallowed hard. “I do too … care about you, I mean.” That was an understatement. She was totally lost, in love with this beautiful man.
Brent hugged her and muttered, “Clancy is going to pay.”
In spite of the warmth of Brent’s hug, she groaned and shivered in fear for him.
*****
In this excerpt from “Marlie” we have the POV in third person, past tense, and we are in Marlie’s head. This is how third person should be done, with no slips into first person.
“You were going to show me your carvings,” she said.
“Oh yeah.” Clancy took a swig and set the beer down on a wooden crate that served as coffee table. “But first, I need a little kiss.” He pulled her close and kissed her with that horrible beer breath.
She pushed him away, but he kept an iron grip on her upper arms.
“Clancy!” She hit at his shoulders and twisted away. “That’s not funny.”
He grabbed her wrist tightly. “No, not funny,” he said, “but it’s fun.” He laughed and yanked her closer and tried to kiss her again, groping at her breasts with one hand. “Told you we’d have fun.”
Now she was scared. She was all alone in the bush with a guy she hardly knew. What ever had possessed her to come here alone with him? She must have been crazy. She didn’t know Clancy. She’d only met him two weeks earlier and the comments from people who knew him had nothing good to say about him. Why hadn’t she listened? She was only trying to be polite, coming in to see his artwork. Suckered! She couldn’t believe she was so stupid.
Clancy grabbed the back of her hair. “I love your hair, Marlie. There’s so much of it.” He pulled it back so hard that her knees buckled and she fell backwards onto the couch, just as he must have planned it. She scratched his face to make him let go, but he threw his bloodied head back and laughed like an insane man, taunting her with a sound like a cat yowling. “Bit of a wildcat, eh?”
When she bit his arm he jumped back, shocked, and then slapped the side of her head with the back of his hand. Her head roared inside like blood rushing around in her skull, and her ears were ringing. Clancy reached up and grabbed a coil of rope that hung on a nail by the door.
*****
This section from Orion’s Gift is in first person, past tense. We are in Sylvia’s head.
I asked directions and learned that the Banamex was only a few blocks away in the business part of town. As I entered the bank, the security guard gave me a disapproving look. He stole frequent glances in my direction as I sat in the row of chairs in the waiting area with my queue number in my hand. A woman sitting at the far end of my row gave me the same disapproving look.
Do I have a smudge of dirt on me? For sure something was wrong. I felt very uncomfortable, as if I didn’t belong here. I settled back to wait my turn. The young Mexican woman sitting next to me leaned over and said, “Is your way of to dress.”
I looked down at my shorts and T-shirt and realized I had dressed like a camper, not a business person.
“Is not the custom to have the arms and the legs so … not covered,” she whispered. “Not in the bank. Maybe … en la playa … the beach.”
“Oh, dear.” I felt my face get hot. “I’m so sorry. I had no idea.”
“I know. Is why I tell you. For next time.” She patted my hand.
“Thank you so much. Muchas gracias.” I winced and gave her a little smile as I curled my shoulders, trying to shrink inside myself.
I couldn’t wait to escape. When my queue number came up on the digital display, I paid my tourist card fee and changed more dollars to pesos. The teller, a woman about my age, with her black hair pulled straight back and fastened in a chignon, was all business. She raised her nose slightly higher in disdain, brightly painted orange lips twitching disrespect. I scooped up the pesos she shoved through the wicket at me and rushed out of the bank. As I glanced hastily over my shoulder, I saw the security guard craning his neck for one last look at my legs.
*****
Some stories are better told in first person and some are better in third person. Some lend themselves to the present tense while others are better in the past tense. If you’re not sure which is best for your novel, why not try a few paragraphs in both and compare? Just don’t leave any loose threads like the ones I confessed to earlier in this post.
*****
If you go to amazon.com or amazon.ca you will see all my books on that page. They are also available on smashwords.com where you can download them in a format to suit your brand of e-reader.
Anneli, I have never even heard of this first, second, and third POV thing. Apparently, writing a novel is not in my future. Still, I find this very interesting. You are very good at this! I like your photo.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Now I have to confess that the photo was taken “some” years ago. But on the POV subject, it it something I had to learn and I admit it was not an easy thing to figure out at first.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I believe you, difficult!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I always get in a horrible muddle with POV!
LikeLiked by 1 person
It is one of the more difficult things to get right in our writing. Imagining the camera in the character’s head helped me figure it out. But as you read, it is still not failproof.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I tend to get caught up in the story, and forget these details…
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s okay as long as you remember to clean it up afterwards. Sometimes, when you’re on a roll it’s more important to get the story down first. Lots of time for rewriting and editing later (but preferably before publishing).
LikeLiked by 1 person
but of course. I rely on Grammarly to pick up what I miss…
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s a good start.
LikeLike
Excellent overview, Anneli! And kudos on your book Marlie!
Genre can play into the POV choice. Although readers may not know which POV, most have pre-established preferences for the books they like to read. When the author uses a POV unexpected for the genre, readers often share their disappoint in the reviews. Amazon is a fantastic lens on what readers expect for any genre.
For example, Third-Person Limited is the preferred POV for many of the bestselling thrillers.
LikeLiked by 1 person
So true. And readers do have preferences. I know I find first person present tense really irky, but once I get into the book it’s all right.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I cut my writing-teeth using the first person present tense POV for three novellas geared for grade-schoolers. Never again! (Well, not in the near term, anyway.)
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well, I didn’t notice the POV switch, and I’m one who usually does. Maybe I assumed it was her thoughts or was wrapped up in the story or saw it but didn’t care–just wanted to read.
How did you ever find it?
LikeLiked by 1 person
The funny thing was that I was looking for an excerpt to show POV and I came across the mistake in POV. I was so horrified to think that this oversight had been out there all this time and I didn’t know it. I took the book off the market, was going to give up on publishing (I was in such a flap). But my friend who did the paperback layout still had the file and fixed it for me right away, so I was able to re-publish the paperback with corrections done. I also did the e-book version but was able to do that myself. Whew! Just goes to show, it can happen to anyone.
LikeLike
Before I found you, I was always republishing books with changes, as efriends pointed stuff out. Mind you, I did try to clean it to perfection prior to publishing, but it just didn’t work.
Enter Anneli.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think between us, we’ve just proven what I always suspected. We don’t see our own mistakes because, before our eyes read the words, our brains tell us what the words say because we made them up and we know what it says (or should say). So we skim over mistakes because we assume it says what we intended. This is why another set of eyes (without the preconceived idea of what it will say) is a good thing. But I am glad you found me and I found you because I love reading your books and if you’re happy with my editing it works out for everyone.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think your mistake, Anneli, proves that you were truly in your character’s head! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think you’re right, Carol. I was living the scene with her, but still, I should have known better. AND, I should have caught that mistake sooner. But thank you for the kind thought.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I remember when I went to my first critique group about 17 years ago, and they told me I couldn’t use omniscient point of view. I was skeptical at first, because like you, I’d read past authors who’d done that. Of course, I eventually realized things had changed. Thanks for sharing your tips.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It was so hard to get my head around that one, but I finally got it. It’s not an easy concept at first, but once you start using it, it becomes second nature.
LikeLiked by 1 person
When I’m writing in the 3rd person, I always pretend that I’m writing in the 1st person but using 3rd person pronouns. That helps to remind me whose head I’m in. 🤪
LikeLiked by 1 person
That sounds like a good plan.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Anneli, thank you for sharing from your writing journey. While a novel probably won’t be on my radar screen, I still dabble with crafting short stories. It can be fun to experiment with a first-person POV once in awhile.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, it’s fun to try them out. All kinds of writing are done from some kind of POV, so it’s good to know about it no matter what you write. Thanks for your visit. Have a great weekend.
LikeLike